Ethan,
A spirited debate can be found on the Authentic Campaigner website: (
http://www.authentic-campaigner.com/for ... Cal-Kinzer) with regards to a wide range of opinions about how to look 'authentic'.
As leggins being part of dress uniform--yes they were. But since they were issued on only one occassion (Caspar Trepp's Quartermaster report for Dec 1861 show 98 leggings, 98 knapsacks, 98 hats and 98 greatcoats (Seamless Clothing grey felt 'waterproofs'); among other issuances. But this does not translate that every man would have had them present for the March 1863 review. Granted, Brian White's research on "Painted Tent" images of USSS of that time frame (March-April; possibly May-June 1st) show a few men still posing for photos wearing the leggings; but others do not.
I believe the larger issue here is: Do I follow orders from my company commander? We are part of a 'reenacting' Army. Like the original volunteers our officers and NCO's are elected to those positions for a variety of reasons. During the CW, in private life they were likely distinguished citizens of the community; some already having been elected to positions of the public trust (mayor, sherriff, etc.). Recruiting for companies were no different--these men were offered commissions if they could bring enough qualified (?) men to serve in the army. Those that did so, recieved commissions that reflected their recruiting success (Col-1000 men) and ability to network/politic with other men (Capt=100 men) to form a regiment.
I have had the opportunity to serve under some truly inspiring leaders and some where I looked behind their tent to find the Cracker Jack box their bars came out of. Despite the differences, I try to do my small part in 'honoring the memory of the original men' by following orders and doing my duty. The Minnesota Sharpshooter muster out rolls for esteemed veterans had a simple epithet: (He was) "A brave and good soldier". There can be no higher compliment to aspire to.
Bill Skillman
Hudson Squad, USSS